Angry Orchard Stone Dry

Review of Angry Orchard’s newest variety, Stone Dry.  It is their driest Core selection, and described as a twist on English cider.

This is a review of a sample bottle provided to Cider Says by Angry Orchard.  Although I will take care to treat it the same as any other review, there is always the potential for bias as I received this for free.  The only consideration I knowingly made was pushing this up in my cider review cue, considering it is a new release and the info may be helpful for folks deciding to purchase it.  I love free stuff, especially cider!  Want your cider or cider-related product reviewed here?  Contact me.

2015-09-25 19.11.10

They send me two bottles, a fact sheet, a note from head cider maker Ryan Burk, and a large quantity of bubble wrap (not pictured).

Cider:  Stone Dry
Cidery:  Angry Orchard
Cidery Location:  Walden NY (their new R&D facility)
Cider Production Locations:  Cincinnati OH & Breingsville PA
ABV:  5.5%
How Supplied:  six pack of 12oz bottles
(will also have limited draft availability to start, nationwide in 2016)

2015-09-26 18.02.262015-09-26 18.01.48

Ingredient List:  Hard cider, water, sugar, apple juice concentrate, carbon dioxide, malic acid and sulfites to preserve freshness

2015-09-26 18.01.56 2015-09-26 18.02.03

Availability:  year round, wide release, launched 09/24/2015 (part of their Core collection)

Fact Sheet from Angry Orchard: For more than two decades, the cider makers at Angry Orchard have been experimenting with ingredients from all over the world and tinkering with recipes to perfect the craft of cider making in the U.S.  In the UK – where cider is 15% of the beer segment, as opposed to around 1% in the U.S. – traditional English dry ciders have been around for centuries and are a cultural mainstay.  These styles are known for their use of traditional bittersweet apple varieties and showcasing naturally occurring tannins that create a drying effect on the palate.

Angry Orchard Stone Dry – the driest cider in Angry Orchard’s core collection – is an American interpretation of the traditional English dry cider style. It offers a bright apple aroma, juicy flavor, and a clean dry finish, showcasing an intricate balance between the sweetness and acidity of culinary apples and the tannins of traditional cider making apples. The traditional apples chosen by the cider makers are European bittersweet varieties like Dabinett, Binet Rouge, and Harry Masters Jersey, which contribute to the high tannic character and dry finish. The result is a refreshing, slightly puckering cider with a drying finish, most often felt on the middle of your tongue and the front part of your mouth.

While most of the juice from apples in the cider is fermented, Angry Orchard’s cider makers add a bit of non-fermented bittersweet apple juice into the cider during the post-fermentation stage to help achieve this cider’s balanced, dry taste.  This results in Stone Dry’s fuller tannic mouthfeel as well as perceived dryness and robust bittersweet aromatic notes – much like a very ripe apple.

As the palates of American cider drinkers have continued to grow in sophistication and evolve with the increasing popularity of hard cider here, Angry Orchard has developed a broad range of cider styles for drinkers to try and to showcase what American cider can be, including the newest year-round offering.

Angry Orchard Stone Dry pairs well with a wide variety of foods, from porcine plates to seafood dishes.  This take on a traditional European dry style cider is an excellent accompaniment to charcuterie, including cured meats and aged cheeses, and is a great introduction to fall foods and heartier dishes or stews with root vegetables.  It can also be used as an ingredient in recipes, such as mussels steamed in Angry Orchard Stone Dry cider.

Price:  retails for $7.50 a six pack in my area, although Angry Orchard’s fact sheet said $8.99-10.99
Where Bought:  n/a
Where Drank:  home
How Found:  on my doorstep

2015-09-26 18.04.22

First Impression:  Amber hue with very little carbonation.  They got quite a bit of color out of this one.  Dry “cheap” apple scent….I just didn’t pick up much nose to this one.

Opinion:  Semi-dry.  Mild bitterness, tannins, astringency, and acidity.  Simple flavor.  Almost watered down tasting.  I get a bit of that bittersweet apple flavor, but this doesn’t remind me of English style cider at all (which to me often have a really rich flavor).  Quick finish.  Definitely more drinkable than their other varieties I’ve had (which is most of them), but I’m not impressed.  More flavor would definitely be nice.  Its unfortunate they use apple juice concentrate (and water & sugar oddly enough!).  It tastes like they were trying to eek some tannins out of dessert apples, although they note the use of bittersweet apples.

I find it interesting their description indicates more a drying flavor (which I’d call astringency) than dryness (lack of sweetness).  I actually through their fact sheet was kinda funny, coming from the biggest commercial cidermaker in the U.S.  It seems they are trying to reconnect with craft cidermaking, between releasing this variety and moving into an R&D facility with a 60 acre orchard earlier this year (article).  They have plans to open a tasting room there in the fall for their small batch creations.

Comparison to Woodchuck Gumption:  It seems this may be Angry Orchard’s response to Woodchuck’s latest hit, Gumption (in addition to responding to requests for a drier cider in general).  So, I thought a comparison was in order. Note that I didn’t however have a bottle of Gumption available (I may have to get one for a side by side test with my second bottle of Stone Dry), so I went by memory and notes. They both incorporate bittersweet apples and aim to make a drier cider for their core collection.  Stone Dry comes across as significantly drier than Gumption (even more so than the 7 vs. 13 grams of sugar per 12 oz would indicate).  Where it gets interesting is the calories, 150 for Stone Dry vs. 220 for Gumption (for equivalent ABV).  I found Gumption to be more flavorful and more rich in general.  Stone Dry includes concentrate (and water & sugar) where Gumption doesn’t.  However, Gumption is listed to have “natural flavor”.  Gumption gets my vote as far as likability, although for someone that wants the driest easily found commercial cider available, Stone Dry may be a good choice.  The driest commercial cider I’ve ever seen by the way is Ace Joker, which only has an impressive 3 grams of sugar per 12 oz, but it isn’t quite as readily available (I have a bottle of Joker at home to try).

Closing Notes:   Not bad.  Definitely drinkable.  If a bar had this and no other cider, I’d buy it.  I won’t on the other hand pay for Angry Orchard’s Crisp Apple variety, which is too syrupy for my liking.  Stone Dry is an above average commercial offering, but I wouldn’t in any way say this is a craft cider (neither would I describe Woodchuck as craft though).

Have you tried Angry Orchard Stone Dry?  What did you think?

8 thoughts on “Angry Orchard Stone Dry

  1. I’m very underwhelmed by the Stone Dry. I was looking forward to it when I bought it the other day, but when I cracked open my first one with my dinner tonight I was quickly let down. I have tried a few ciders, though I wouldn’t say I am knowledgeable at all – I just know I don’t like things too sweet. Angry Orchard Dry has been my go-to, but I will drink the Crisp Apple in a pinch (like when I am broke and have to buy just a single can). This one is too bland. There is a hint of flavor, no bite at all, and it’s really more boring than plain sparkling water. I think I will grab a couple cans of the regular and mix them, to get through the rest of my six pack.

    Liked by 1 person

    • That could probably work. What area do you live in? I could probably recommend some ciders. Woodchuck and Crispin are two easily available commercial ciders. Woodchuck Amber (the most common) is pretty sweet, but they have some drier ones. I’m a huge fan of Woodchuck Winter Chill and Barrel Select, available in winter. Their new Gumption is also tasty. Crispin also has a Brut variety even drier than their Original. My favorite ciders however are the higher end craft ones, especially local and barrel aged.


  2. And I’m glad I stumbled on your review – I was let down by this cider and on a whim thought I’d see if I could find somebody who’s tried it, and I am happily slightly more educated about ciders now 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I tasted something metallic about this cider. Its ok. I’ll drink it. I won’t buy it again. I don’t like ciders that have added sugar or water so I’m not sure why I even bought this in the first place. So far, the only cider I’ve found that’s consistently available in Boston with no added sugar, water or preservatives is Harpoon which I do like. I’ve never understood the reason to add preservatives to alcohol… isn’t alcohol a preservative?

    Liked by 1 person

    • They add sorbates as a preservative to 95% of ciders to stop fermentation. It is more difficult and risky without. A small percent of folks are sensitive to it, but for most folks its no big deal. Thanks for reading!


  4. I very much enjoy the nice dry snap this cider bears; it’s not cloyingly sweet and it has a good enough apple flavor to satisfy my palate.

    That palate might be a wee bit odd compared to the norm, as I’ve been diabetic for more than 10 years and have trained myself to enjoy much lower levels of sweetness than I think the usual Unitedstatesian would prefer.

    Getting the extra 10% or so of ethanol (over most mainstream US ciders) out of this bargain might be a wee bonus, if I drank cider to get slaminated, but they are just a nice, occasional treat for me.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s